The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian: a Challenged Book
There are many things happening right now in our world of books. Books being banned because of issues like alcohol abuse in families and racism. One book that has been debated about was “The Absolutely True diary of a Part-Time Indian” by Sherman Alexie. This book is about a boy named Arnold, who makes a huge move that no one in his Indian Reservation has done, transferred from his local high school of Wellpinit, to the rich white school in another town 22 miles away called Rearden. He is constantly struggling to be accepted in both communities, called a traitor to his Indian people, while being a stranger to the white people of Rearden. This book deals with alcohol abuse and death, as well as having strong language, causing its banning from our libraries.
The theme of tolerance is very prevalent in this book. Arnold has to try and be accepted into both communities, But he struggles to do so because the racism going towards him from the Rearden community. At Rearden, while get stared at by others, he also receives racist remarks from them. They call him things like “Chief, Tonto, Squawboy, & Sitting Bull” because of his native Indian heritage. There is a scene that really shows the racism, “ Hey Chief,” Roger said. “You want to hear a joke?” “Sure” I said. “Did you know that Indians are living proof that n***ers f**k buffalo?”(Alexie 64). This quote really shows one of the reasons this book was banned because of the racism inside if it. But later on in the story, when Roger has tried to befriend Arnold (and partially succeeded), Arnold makes it to the Varsity basketball team where he gains the respect of the team, school, and most parents.
Another significant theme in the book is alcohol. Arnold's father is an alcoholic, who can hardly control his habit to drink. In the book, there is a piece that really shows alcohol abuse. " When the holidays rolled around, we didn't have any money for presents, so Dad did what he always does when we don't have enough money. He took what little money we did have and ran away to get drunk. He left on Christmas Eve and came back on January 2nd". This shows the effect of alcohol on Arnold. But his dad also, saved him five dollars for Christmas, showing how Arnold can still realise that his father is still a father towards him. Another reason Alcohol is prevalent is when Arnold's sister dies from being drunk and knocked out, then her trailer burning down. This shows the harshness of the story, but it also shows Arnold how to deal with death.
Many believe that this book, should be banned because of the strong language, & racism in the book. In one part of the book, Earl(Arnold’s girlfriend’s father) said”Kid, if you get my daughter pregnant, if you make some charcoal babies…(Alexie 109). And there is also the constant feeling of separation in between the communities. Also, people say that this book should be banned because of language. The word “sh*t” appears multiple times in the text from Arnold and many around him. But these themes in the book are supported the 1st Amendment, stating freedom of speech for all, meaning books like this can stay in our libraries. In the article “Darkness Too Visible” by Meghan Cox Gurdon, inside her article Alexie says “ It almost makes me happy to hear that books have that kind of power”.
Overall, I feel that the social commentary in this book, and the bravery of Arnold triumphs, and I feel that this book should not be banned. Even though it has some certain objectionable content, it teaches many life lessons and opens up something new to literature.